At a Glance:
The Mask – What Caregiving Roles Don’t Reveal
The Cost – How Caregiving Reactivates Old Pain
The Threshold – The Breaking Point Between Duty and Self
The Mirror – How To Care Without Betraying Yourself
What Caregiving Roles Don’t Reveal
We’ve been taught that caregiving is a virtue.
That family means sacrifice. That love looks like showing up — no matter what came before.
But what if the one you’re caring for… is the one who once hurt you?
This is the silent reality for many Gen Xers and elder millennials, especially eldest daughters.
Midlife finds them parenting their own kids while tending to aging parents — parents who may have once neglected, harmed, or shamed them.
In caregiving circles, we rarely talk about this. We speak of burnout, but not the emotional whiplash of tucking in the very parent who never tucked you in.
We speak of duty, but not the ache of brushing the hair of the mother who once called you names.
We speak of compassion, but not of the child inside you who’s still waiting for an apology that never came.
Because in families where love came with pain, caregiving doesn’t just feel hard. It feels like betrayal — of the boundaries you fought so hard to build.
And in pretending it’s “just stress,” we miss the truth:
For many, caregiving is not just a responsibility. It’s a return to the scene of the wound.
How Caregiving Reactivates Old Pain
In a landmark study, Kong et al. (2021) found that 9.4 – 26% of adult caregivers experienced childhood maltreatment by the very parents they now care for.
The psychological cost is significant. These adult children report:
Higher levels of depression and anxiety
Re-triggering during caregiving tasks involving physical closeness (e.g., bathing, feeding)
Feelings of helplessness, obligation, and emotional numbing
A collapse of boundaries as old roles resurface
As the study notes:
“When the individual had no choice as a child — and still feels they have none now — it is not just caregiving. It is retraumatization.”
(Clin Gerontol, 2021)
Other studies echo this.
One review (Barczyk et al., 2020) found that caregiving under these conditions leads to “ambiguous loss” — a grief process marked by unresolved emotional tension.
You grieve the parent you wish you had. You grieve the childhood you didn’t get. And now, you grieve your present peace.
Even healthcare professionals often miss this. They see physical strain, not the emotional landmines.
They don’t ask:
“What does it mean for you to be doing this?”
“Was this relationship ever safe?”
And so, many adult children begin to feel something they can’t name:
A blend of guilt and rage.
A push-pull between obligation and self-preservation.
A silent reactivation of roles they swore they’d never return to.
The Breaking Point Between Duty and Self
There’s a lie we carry from childhood:
“If I do enough, they will change.” “If I give enough, they’ll finally see me.” “If I show up, it will rewrite the past.”
But caregiving isn’t always redemptive. And love doesn’t always repair what was never acknowledged.
Developmental studies (e.g., Kong et al., 2021; Schulz et al., 2012) show that a caregiver’s sense of agency is critical. When you feel you’ve chosen this role, not been forced into it, your mental health outcomes improve. When you feel you can say no — or define your own terms — you’re more likely to access growth, not just grief.
But too often, adult children feel trapped in the same double bind they knew growing up:
Speak up, and be called ungrateful.
Step back, and be called selfish.
Show up, and feel invisible all over again.
The threshold moment comes when we realize this: Healing does not require proximity. And caregiving does not have to mean reenacting the old script.
The most transformative act may not be bathing the parent who once neglected you. It might be naming what they never could. It might be redefining what care looks like on your terms.
How To Care Without Betraying Yourself
What experts suggest noticing, protecting, and redefining if you're in this position:
Caregiving after trauma isn’t a question of willpower. It’s a navigation through layered, unspoken grief.
Here’s what trauma-informed researchers and psychologists suggest:
Name the complexity
“Mixed emotions are not signs of dysfunction. They’re signs of depth.” — Dr. Pauline Boss, Ambiguous Loss
You can love and resent someone at the same time. You can show up for care while still mourning the care you never received.
Naming this helps you step out of shame — and into agency.
Define your own terms
“Posttraumatic growth becomes possible when caregivers feel empowered to shape their caregiving roles.” — Schulz et al., 2012
Support doesn’t have to mean 24/7 care. It can mean arranging help, setting financial boundaries, or limiting emotional access.
You’re allowed to care in a way that doesn’t cost you your nervous system.
Prioritize psychological safety
“If caregiving tasks trigger trauma responses, seek support not just for logistics —but for emotional processing.”
Therapists trained in trauma can help navigate this terrain. So can support groups that honor not just the parent — but the wounded child within you.
Let care look different
“Sometimes the most loving act is a boundary.” — Brené Brown, 2012
Caring may mean showing up — but differently. Or it may mean stepping back— with love and clarity.
There is no “right” way to navigate this. Only the most honest way available to you right now.
You don’t owe anyone your retraumatization. You don’t need to sacrifice your healing to be seen as “good.”
The parent-child contract wasn’t broken when you set the boundary. It was broken when your safety was first compromised.
This issue may not have tidy solutions. But you’re not alone in this reckoning. And naming it is the first act of reclaiming your peace.
We see you. We honor your complexity.
See you next Saturday
Team Rebuild
P.S. If you liked this newsletter, share it with your friends and colleagues Rebuild