At a Glance
The Mask – How early maturity can be mistaken for emotional health.
The Cost – What childhood anxiety hides behind the praise.
The Insight – What research reveals about emotional suppression and social delay.
The Solution – How to rebuild from “good kid” conditioning.
The Mask – “So Mature for Their Age”
Many adults today recall being told how mature they were as children.
In classrooms, they were praised. At home, they rarely needed “discipline.” But this wasn’t a sign of emotional resilience—it was often a coping strategy born out of chronic anxiety, rooted in inconsistent emotional safety.
Recent findings from Nakamura et al. (2009) in The Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment reveal that children who internalize their emotions often score higher on scales for anxiety and withdrawal, while receiving fewer external behavior interventions. This suggests that “model behavior” can mask emotional distress.
In simpler terms: children who never act out may still be struggling. You just can’t see it on the surface.
The Cost – What the Praise Covered Up
When kids are praised for being overly mature or undemanding, they can internalize emotional self-suppression as a virtue.
In Complex PTSD: From Surviving to Thriving, trauma therapist Pete Walker describes this as “abandonment depression” — a learned behavior where children minimize their needs to avoid rejection. These kids often grow into adults who:
Struggle to express feelings
Experience chronic self-doubt or “imposter syndrome”
Feel disconnected in relationships, despite deep longing for connection
In fact, the longitudinal work by Eisenberg et al. (2001) and Gross & John (2003) shows that children who are socialized to over-control emotions tend to:
Have poorer social functioning in adolescence
Show lower resilience to future stress
Experience difficulties with self-assertion and boundaries
The worst part? These patterns often go unnoticed until adulthood — showing up as depression, perfectionism, people-pleasing, or chronic burnout.
The Insight – What the Research Shows
Here’s what psychological and developmental studies reveal about children praised for being “mature” too early:
1. Emotional Suppression Inhibits Connection
Studies by James Gross (2003) found that suppression reduces visible emotion but increases internal stress and reduces social closeness. Suppressors experience more negative emotion over time and are rated as less emotionally available by peers.
Suppression might look composed—but it's neurologically taxing and socially distancing.
Inhibited children (Kagan, 1989) may show calm exteriors but often have overactive amygdalas, signaling high internal anxiety. These children tend to experience slower emotional development despite appearing outwardly mature.
Maturity was often anxiety with good manners.
3. Parentification Stunts Self-Development
Children who feel emotionally responsible for parents (Jurkovic, 1997) struggle with identity formation. They bypass their own needs to manage adults' emotions—resulting in a “false self” that’s hard to dismantle later.
These children grow up unsure how to center themselves—because they never learned how.
The Solution: Help Your “Good Kid” Feel Safe Enough to Be Real
We don’t need to unteach maturity — we need to untangle it from fear.
Here’s how:
Normalize Expression, Not Just Behavior
Encourage your child to talk about all feelings — especially “messy” ones like sadness or anger. According to The Whole-Brain Child by Siegel & Bryson, naming emotions calms the limbic system and fosters emotional regulation.
Model Emotional Authenticity
Kids mimic emotional patterns. When parents safely express vulnerability (“I feel nervous too sometimes”), it teaches children that emotions aren’t threats, but signals.
Prioritize Co-Regulation
Research from Lunkenheimer et al. (2020) confirms that co-regulation between caregiver and child (being a calm, attuned presence during their stress) significantly improves a child’s long-term emotional regulation and relational skills.
Watch for False Praise
Avoid saying, “You’re so mature for not crying.” Instead try, “It’s okay to cry — I’m here with
Not every well-behaved child is emotionally well. Sometimes, they’ve just learned to stay small so no one leaves.
But they don’t need applause for their silence. They need space for their truth.
And as parents, teachers, or caregivers — we can give that space.
Were you also the “mature one”? What part of you got left behind?
Reply or share this with someone who’s just beginning to realize: they were never “too much”—they were simply too alone.
Thanks for reading.
See you soon!
Team Rebuild
P.S. If you liked this newsletter, share it with your friends and colleagues Rebuild